+- Forums (https://gelsenkirchen1904.de)
+-- Forum: My Category (https://gelsenkirchen1904.de/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: My Forum (https://gelsenkirchen1904.de/forum-2.html)
+--- Thema: The Controversy of Barry Bonds’ Non-Inclusion in MLB The Show 26 (/thread-133.html)
The Controversy of Barry Bonds’ Non-Inclusion in MLB The Show 26 - SilentArrow - 30.04.2026
Barry Bonds’ absence from MLB The Show 26 has once again sparked heated debate among baseball fans and gamers alike. As the all-time home run leader with 762 career homers, his continued exclusion from the game is one of the most talked-about topics in the MLB gaming community. Despite his monumental achievements on the field, Bonds remains absent from the official rosters, and the reasons behind this have more to do with business and licensing decisions than anything else.
The Core of the Controversy: Why He Is Missing
The reason for Bonds’ exclusion from MLB The Show isn’t a direct ban or disciplinary action; it’s rooted in licensing issues and personal business decisions that stretch back more than 20 years.
Withdrawal from MLBPA
In 2003, Bonds made a decision that would have lasting implications for his presence in baseball video games. He became the first player in history to opt out of the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) collective licensing agreement. Most players allow the MLBPA to handle their Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) rights, allowing game developers like San Diego Studio (SDS) to include them in video games as part of a large collective deal. However, Bonds decided to retain full control over his NIL rights, meaning SDS could not simply include him in the game by purchasing the MLBPA's rights.
Financial Disconnect
The issue goes deeper than just the opt-out decision, though. Reports suggest that Bonds’ demand for compensation is significantly higher than what SDS is willing to pay for individual legends. While many players are included as part of a blanket deal, Bonds’ status as a unique and high-profile player means his licensing deal would come at a much higher price. SDS, known for keeping costs reasonable for player licensing, likely finds it financially unfeasible to meet Bonds’ demands, particularly for a single player.
The "Jeter Treatment"
Some fans speculate that Bonds may only agree to be included in MLB The Show under very specific circumstances. They suggest that, similar to Derek Jeter’s inclusion in the game, Bonds might require a more prominent role—perhaps a dedicated “Storylines” mode or cover athlete status. However, MLB itself, which also holds the license to the game, has been reluctant to give Bonds such a platform, given his controversial role in the "steroid era" of baseball.
Community Reaction and "Workarounds"
As you might expect, Bonds' absence has generated strong reactions from the fanbase. His legendary status and impact on the game make his exclusion feel like an incomplete historical representation for many players. Over the years, the community has come up with creative ways to fill the Bonds-shaped void in MLB The Show.
Reggie Stocker & Jon Dowd
In previous years, developers have opted to use "placeholder" players, like Reggie Stocker (MLB The Show) or Jon Dowd (MVP Baseball), who shared Bonds’ stats and batting stance but did not use his name or likeness. These players were essentially stand-ins, mimicking Bonds’ power-hitting style without the legal and financial complexities of licensing his real name.
Custom Rosters
Another popular workaround in the MLB The Show community is the use of the "Create-a-Player" mode. Many players have taken it upon themselves to manually recreate Barry Bonds within the game, meticulously adjusting his equipment, batting stance, and appearance to match his real-life counterpart. This allows fans to have a virtual version of Bonds in their Franchise mode or online play, though it’s not the same as officially having him on the roster.
"April Fools" Pranks
Bonds' absence has even led to some playful pranks. On April 1, 2026, a viral TikTok claimed that Bonds had finally been added to MLB The Show 26, sending waves of excitement through the community. Fans eagerly shared the news, only to find out it was an April Fools' joke. This short-lived excitement highlighted just how much fans still yearn for Bonds' inclusion in the game.
Latest Inclusion Status
As of late April 2026, Barry Bonds is not officially included in the MLB The Show 26 base roster or any of the game's legend reveals. While other high-profile legends like Albert Pujols and Dustin Pedroia have made their way into the game this year, Bonds remains absent. It’s a decision that continues to frustrate many long-time fans who feel that the game’s historical roster isn’t complete without the player who once set the all-time home run record.
The controversy surrounding Barry Bonds’ non-inclusion in MLB The Show 26 is a reminder of how complex the intersection of sports, business, and personal choice can be. Despite his undeniable legacy, Bonds remains outside the game due to a combination of licensing issues, financial demands, and the larger context of his role in baseball history. For now, fans will have to make do with workarounds or continue to hope for a resolution that sees Bonds back in the game he helped elevate through his incredible feats on the field.